Do you use light or lightning?

I compared smite priests to elemental shamans before thanks to Elowyn the Master Bear’s theory crafting. This post is going to look more at the spells and rotations available, similar to the previous healing priest versus restoration shaman article.

If you’re willing to forgo flat numbers—because, as discussed earlier with smite priests and shadow priests, it’s just inevitable these standard DPS specs are going to do more DPS than an underdog spec—the smite priest still has some unique things that the elemental shaman does not.

For starters, let’s say your smite priest is the only priest in the raid. I know this is not as likely as your shaman being the only shaman in the raid, but work with me in a 10-man scenario here. These are some things an elemental shaman will bring to the raid, and then there’s the things the smite priest will bring:

• Heroism versus Power Infusion. Heroism (or Bloodlust) has a 10-minute debuff that makes it useful only once per encounter. Power Infusion, on the other hand, may be used multiple times per boss encounter, and also grants reduction to mana costs in addition to haste. Power Infusion’s drawback is that it does not affect the entire raid–only one lucky individual. (Which, when you’re smiting, is usually you.)
• Priest Buffs versus Totems. Does Divine Spirit, Power Word: Fortitude, Shadow Protection, and Fear Ward stack up to shaman totems, especially in situations like Onyxia where Tremor Totem just seems to crush Fear Ward into the ground? It’s hard to say. Most guilds thrive off the universal benefit of having more Spirit and Stamina throughout a raid, while the totems give the versatility of switch-up fight-to-fight. In terms of resistance, the shaman can cover everything except shadow, which is ironically found in the Shadow Protection of the priest (or in a paladin’s aura.)
• Elemental Oath versus Renewed Hope. It’s a question of whether you want destruction or survival. Renewed Hope is going to reduce the damage the raid is taking by 3%, while Elemental Oath is going to grant 5% spell crit to your casting classes. In a raid that is mostly energy and rage based, it’s obvious which one wins; otherwise, the situation is subjective. A boomkin is also going to neutralize Elemental Oath, while a fellow Discipline priest is going to neutralize Renewed Hope.

What about the rotation?

Rotation-speaking, both classes can potentially have a “mash” button. As you can see from the Lvl 80 Smite Priest Raiding Guide though, it’s about as smart to mash Smite with a smite priest as it is to mash Lightning Bolt with an elemental shaman. Ideal DPS just doesn’t output from it.

Smite priests also have a harder time getting a grasp on a “rotation” than elemental shamans because they blow their GCD a random whenever Surge of Light procs and gives them a free Smite. This is different from the elemental shaman’s Lightning Overload, which throws the Lightning Bolt out free of charge and free of GCD. The elemental shaman can make a macro, adjusted based on their haste, that rotates through their spells with ease; the smite priest’s macro, on the other hand, is going to be totally squandered by GCD’s being thrown off.

Ultimately though, the only “win button” the smite priest has over the elemental shaman is this: you find yourself in a predicament where your 10-man raid can’t do a boss with two healers, but only needs that third healer on certain phases. Or, alternatively, you’re smiting and a healer dies. Smite priest heals always win over elemental shaman heals, and this is where your place in the raid will shine.

Thanks to wvs’ Creative Commons photography for this post.

Elowyn says: There’s a few things worth noting.  The above doesn’t take into account haste gained by the elemental shaman through totems (largely because it’s highly variable).  It also doesn’t include haste on gear.  All other stats are based on spot checking of several elemental shamans and holy/discipline priests.  Also worth noting is the critical hit percentages.  Numbers taken were based on similar gear and only differences via talents.  More realistic percentages would put the shaman around 50% crit, increasing the Shaman’s total output by about 15%.

Well, I don’t know what elemental shamans you’ve been hanging out with behind Kourtnie the NINJA’s back Master Elowyn, but I can assure you that—oh wait—nevermind, 50% sounds about right.

Elowyn the Master Bear theorycrafts

So keeping in mind the fundamental flaw of this theorycrafting is that the shaman’s gear and the priest’s gear are going to naturally output different stats, it’s interesting nonetheless to see that smite priest actually beat the elemental shaman by a little under 5% DPS; of course, this is an ideal Elowyn the Master Bear Land where Mana Bars haven’t reared their ugly heads at people and smite priests naturally come upon the same stats that an elemental shaman would.

This is why Johannah needs to hit level 80 and deliver a wonderful Smite Priest WotLK performance to you!

Want to know more about Elowyn the Master Bear? Well, here he is!

Elowyn is the guild master for Momentum, the lolSmite priest loving guild that supported Johannah’s exploits back in the days of Gruul. (I have vague memories of Johannah causing a ruckus in Hyjal as well, but I believe I was playing Kourtnie more than less at that point.) Elowyn is quite possibly the only Jewelcrafter in the universe that can cut a Shining Eye of Zul—that’s how much Elowyn loves the smite priest [player]! Elowyn is either on a raid leading rampage, plundering through a heroic, or standing next to the Dalaran mailbox whispering Kalecgos people that submit to Master Bear. Occasionally—and this is when Master Bear is the happiest—you can find him charging through battlegrounds and arenas. If you have a feral druid question or want someone to theory craft and talk about World of Warcraft for the puck (yeah, I said PUCK) of it, he’s your man!

Elowyn has his own blog that he writes for, Spank This Tank, which focuses mainly on feral druid bear-and-cat-glory-ness. Elowyn has experience as a PvE druid tank and feral DPS, as well as experience as a PvP feral druid, so if you have feral druid questions, I’d recommend him as a good resource.